On the July 5, 2018 episode of Impact!, Baszler made her in-ring debut during a fight for the Distaff Championship pitting Knockouts Champion Riho facing Katarina Carter. She assisted Nyco and Ciampa in the match by attacking Carter with their surprise weapons, until then a non-wrestler. Baszler then helped Carter in the match with ambushes and foot stomps. At the August 17 tapings of Impact! Baszler was pinned by Carter after the first round of the tapings. On the August 24, 2018 episode of Impact!, Baszler defeated Katarina Carter to win the Impact Knockouts Championship by flying headbutt. At Bound for Glory, Baszler successfully defended the Impact Knockouts Championship against Tamina
She later lost the title to Tamina at the October 7, 2018 episode of Impact!. On the October 14, 2018 episode of Impact!, Baszler showed up in Victoria's Secret fashion on the backstage to introduce herself in a backstage segment. During the segment, she challenged Team Impact member and Charles Robinson's fiancee Brandi to a match, and declared that the winner of the match would be her new girlfriend. On the October 20, 2018 episode of Impact!, Baszler made her return during the final match of the year between Mickie James and Brandi, in which James defeated Brandi.
After months of claiming that she did not want to be a part of the company, Eve decided to wrestle again. On March 11, 2019, Eve made her "return" to Impact Wrestling by challenging Tessa Blanchard for the Knockouts Championship. During the match, Eve was accidentally knocked out by Blanchard, who then pinned her for the win and the title. This made Eve the first real challenger for the title as she was the only one to go against Blanchard. On March 13, 2019, it was announced that Eve would no longer be a part of Impact Wrestling after the match, and has been released from her contract. d2c66b5586